Unique Places to Stay in Amish Country Ohio

Introduction

Ohio’s Amish Country is a captivating destination that offers visitors a glimpse into a simpler way of life. With its rolling hills, picturesque farmlands, and charming communities, this region provides a perfect escape from the hustle and bustle of modern life. For those seeking an authentic and memorable experience, exploring the unique places to stay in Amish Country Ohio is an absolute must. From cozy bed and breakfasts to rustic cabins and even treehouses, the accommodation options in this enchanting area are as diverse as they are delightful. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll take you on a journey through some of the most extraordinary lodging choices in Amish Country Ohio, ensuring your visit is nothing short of unforgettable.

Charming Bed and Breakfasts

The Barn Inn Bed and Breakfast

Nestled in the heart of Amish Country Ohio, The Barn Inn Bed and Breakfast offers a truly unique stay experience. This restored 1900s barn has been transformed into a cozy retreat that combines rustic charm with modern amenities. Each room is individually decorated with antique furnishings and handmade quilts, providing a warm and inviting atmosphere. Guests can enjoy stunning views of the surrounding countryside from their private balconies or patios.

The inn’s hearty country breakfasts, featuring homemade Amish pastries and locally sourced ingredients, are a highlight for many visitors. The friendly innkeepers are always happy to share their knowledge of the area, making The Barn Inn an ideal base for exploring Amish Country Ohio.

Honey Run Inn

For those seeking a more intimate experience, the Honey Run Inn is a hidden gem among the unique places to stay in Amish Country Ohio. This small, family-owned bed and breakfast is situated on a quiet country road, offering tranquility and privacy. The inn features just four guest rooms, each with its own distinct character and decor inspired by the natural beauty of the region.

What sets Honey Run Inn apart is its location adjacent to the Honey Run Waterfall, a stunning natural attraction that guests can explore via private hiking trails. The inn’s peaceful setting and proximity to nature make it a perfect choice for couples or solo travelers looking to unwind and reconnect with the great outdoors.

Rustic Cabins and Cottages

The Cabins at Pine Cove

For a more secluded and immersive experience in Amish Country Ohio, The Cabins at Pine Cove offer a perfect retreat. These beautifully crafted log cabins are nestled in a wooded area, providing privacy and a true sense of getting away from it all. Each cabin features a fully equipped kitchen, cozy living area with a fireplace, and a private hot tub on the deck.

Guests can choose from various cabin sizes, accommodating couples, families, or larger groups. The surrounding area offers plenty of opportunities for hiking, fishing, and wildlife watching, making The Cabins at Pine Cove an excellent choice for nature enthusiasts and those seeking a rustic yet comfortable stay in Amish Country Ohio.

Amish Country Lodging

Amish Country Lodging offers a variety of unique cottages and cabins spread throughout the region. What makes these accommodations special is their authentic Amish-built construction and decor. From hand-hewn log cabins to quaint country cottages, each property showcases the craftsmanship and attention to detail that the Amish are known for.

Many of these lodgings are situated on working Amish farms, allowing guests to experience farm life up close. Visitors can watch as Amish farmers tend to their fields using horse-drawn equipment or observe the daily routines of an Amish household. This immersive experience provides a rare opportunity to gain insight into the Amish way of life while enjoying comfortable and unique accommodations.

Treehouses and Unconventional Lodgings

The Mohicans Treehouse Resort

For a truly extraordinary stay in Amish Country Ohio, look no further than The Mohicans Treehouse Resort. This one-of-a-kind property features a collection of stunning treehouses, each uniquely designed and built with sustainable materials. Perched high among the trees, these elevated accommodations offer breathtaking views of the surrounding forest and a sense of childlike wonder.

The treehouses range from cozy and romantic to spacious and family-friendly, with options to suit various group sizes and preferences. Despite their lofty locations, these treehouses are equipped with modern amenities such as electricity, running water, and climate control. A stay at The Mohicans Treehouse Resort is sure to be a memorable highlight of any visit to Amish Country Ohio.

Glenmont Yurts

For those seeking an unconventional lodging experience, Glenmont Yurts offers a unique twist on camping in Amish Country Ohio. These circular, tent-like structures originated in Central Asia but have been adapted to provide a comfortable glamping experience in the heart of Ohio’s countryside.

Each yurt is furnished with comfortable beds, a kitchenette, and a private bathroom, offering the perfect blend of rustic charm and modern convenience. The property features communal fire pits and picnic areas, encouraging guests to socialize and enjoy the great outdoors. Staying in a yurt provides a novel way to experience Amish Country Ohio while still enjoying the comforts of home.

Farm Stays and Agritourism Experiences

Amish Farm Stay Experience

For visitors looking to immerse themselves fully in the Amish way of life, several farms in the region offer unique farm stay experiences. These accommodations allow guests to stay on working Amish farms, participating in daily chores and learning about traditional farming methods.

Visitors can help with tasks such as milking cows, collecting eggs, or tending to the garden. Meals are often shared with the host family, providing an opportunity to sample authentic Amish cuisine and engage in meaningful cultural exchange. While accommodations may be simple, the experience of living alongside an Amish family is truly priceless and offers one of the most unique stays in Amish Country Ohio.

The Farm at Walnut Creek

The Farm at Walnut Creek offers a different kind of farm stay experience, focusing on education and interaction with a wide variety of animals. This working farm features comfortable guest houses where visitors can stay overnight, but the real attraction is the opportunity to get up close with over 500 animals from six continents.

Guests can take guided tours of the farm in horse-drawn wagons, feed exotic animals like giraffes and kangaroos, and learn about sustainable farming practices. The Farm at Walnut Creek provides a perfect blend of unique accommodation and hands-on agricultural experiences, making it an ideal choice for families and animal lovers visiting Amish Country Ohio.

You May Also Like: Travel Backpacks For Men

Historic Inns and Restored Properties

The Inn at Honey Run

The Inn at Honey Run is a luxurious boutique hotel that seamlessly blends with its natural surroundings in Amish Country Ohio. What makes this property unique is its Earth Sheltered Rooms, which are built into the hillside and feature living roofs covered in native plants. These eco-friendly accommodations offer a one-of-a-kind stay experience that connects guests with nature while providing modern comforts.

The inn also features a fine dining restaurant, hiking trails, and an on-site art gallery showcasing works by local artists. Its combination of luxury, sustainability, and cultural offerings makes The Inn at Honey Run a standout among unique places to stay in Amish Country Ohio.

The Olde Fogie Farm

For history buffs and those interested in rural Americana, The Olde Fogie Farm offers a trip back in time. This restored 1820s farmhouse has been lovingly converted into a bed and breakfast that celebrates the region’s rich agricultural heritage. Each room is decorated with antiques and period-appropriate furnishings, creating an authentic 19th-century ambiance.

What sets The Olde Fogie Farm apart is its extensive collection of vintage farm equipment and memorabilia. Guests can explore the property’s barns and outbuildings, which house everything from horse-drawn plows to early gas-powered tractors. The innkeepers offer guided tours and share stories about the farm’s history, providing a unique educational experience alongside comfortable lodging in Amish Country Ohio.

Wellness Retreats and Spa Resorts

The Wallhouse Hotel

For those seeking a more modern and wellness-focused stay in Amish Country Ohio, The Wallhouse Hotel offers a contemporary retreat with a focus on relaxation and rejuvenation. This eco-friendly hotel features spacious rooms with ergonomic furnishings and hypoallergenic bedding, catering to health-conscious travelers.

The hotel’s on-site spa offers a range of treatments inspired by both modern techniques and traditional Amish remedies. Guests can indulge in aromatherapy massages, herbal wraps, and other wellness services. The Wallhouse Hotel’s unique blend of modern amenities and locally-inspired wellness offerings provides a refreshing alternative to more traditional accommodations in the region.

Holmes with a View Cottage & Day Spa

Perched atop a hill with panoramic views of Amish Country Ohio, Holmes with a View Cottage & Day Spa offers a unique combination of private accommodation and spa services. This charming cottage features a fully equipped kitchen, comfortable living areas, and a private deck perfect for taking in the stunning vistas.

What makes this property truly special is its on-site day spa, where guests can enjoy a variety of treatments without leaving the comfort of their accommodation. From massages and facials to reflexology and energy work, the spa services are designed to promote relaxation and well-being. The privacy of the cottage combined with the luxury of on-demand spa treatments creates a one-of-a-kind wellness retreat in the heart of Amish Country Ohio.

Unique Dining Experiences

Der Dutchman Restaurant & Bakery

While not a lodging option itself, Der Dutchman Restaurant & Bakery is worth mentioning for its unique dining experience that complements any stay in Amish Country Ohio. This popular eatery offers authentic Amish cuisine served family-style, allowing visitors to sample a wide variety of traditional dishes.

The restaurant’s large windows provide sweeping views of the surrounding countryside, and guests can watch Amish buggies pass by as they enjoy their meals. The on-site bakery offers an array of freshly baked goods, including the famous Amish fry pies and cinnamon rolls. Many of the unique places to stay in Amish Country Ohio are located near Der Dutchman, making it a must-visit dining destination during your trip.

Amish Home Dinner Experience

For an even more authentic culinary adventure, several tour operators in Amish Country Ohio offer the opportunity to dine in an Amish home. These intimate experiences allow visitors to enjoy a home-cooked meal with an Amish family, learning about their lifestyle and culinary traditions firsthand.

Meals typically feature hearty, farm-fresh ingredients and may include dishes such as roast chicken, mashed potatoes, homemade bread, and shoofly pie. The chance to break bread with an Amish family in their own home provides invaluable cultural insights and is truly one of the most unique experiences available in the region.

Seasonal Events and Festivals

Ohio’s Amish Country Fall Harvest Festival

Visitors planning their stay in Amish Country Ohio during the autumn months should consider timing their trip to coincide with the Fall Harvest Festival. This annual event celebrates the region’s agricultural heritage with a variety of activities and attractions.

Many of the unique accommodations mentioned earlier offer special packages during the festival, allowing guests to fully immerse themselves in the harvest season celebrations. Activities may include apple picking, pumpkin carving contests, hayrides, and craft demonstrations. The festival provides an excellent opportunity to experience the vibrant culture and traditions of Amish Country Ohio while enjoying comfortable and distinctive lodging options.

For those visiting during the winter holidays, the Holmes County Christmas Cookie Tour offers a sweet twist on exploring Amish Country Ohio. This self-guided tour takes participants to various inns, bed and breakfasts, and other unique lodgings throughout the region. At each stop, visitors can sample homemade Christmas cookies and collect recipes to take home.

Many of the participating properties offer special overnight packages for cookie tour attendees, allowing guests to turn the experience into a delightful holiday getaway. The tour not only satisfies the sweet tooth but also provides an opportunity to explore some of the most charming and unique places to stay in Amish Country Ohio during a festive time of year.

Planning Your Unique Stay in Amish Country Ohio

When planning your visit to Amish Country Ohio and choosing among the many unique places to stay, consider the following tips:

Book in advance: Many of the most distinctive accommodations can fill up quickly, especially during peak seasons and events.
Consider the season: Each time of year offers its own charms in Amish Country Ohio, from spring blooms to autumn harvests. Choose a season that aligns with your interests and desired activities.
Respect local customs: If staying in or near Amish communities, be mindful of their customs and lifestyle. This may include dressing modestly and refraining from taking photographs of Amish individuals without permission.
Explore beyond your accommodation: While many of these unique lodgings are destinations in themselves, be sure to venture out and explore the surrounding area, including Amish-owned businesses, scenic drives, and natural attractions.
Try local cuisine: Whether dining at your accommodation or venturing out to local restaurants, don’t miss the opportunity to sample authentic Amish and regional specialties.
Engage with locals: Many innkeepers and hosts are wealth of knowledge about the area. Don’t hesitate to ask for recommendations or insights about Amish Country Ohio.

Transportation and Accessibility

Getting to and around Amish Country Ohio is an important aspect of planning your unique stay. The region is primarily located in Holmes County, with parts extending into neighboring counties.

Getting There

The nearest major airports are John Glenn Columbus International Airport (about 2 hours away) and Cleveland Hopkins International Airport (about 1.5 hours away). From these airports, renting a car is the most convenient option for reaching Amish Country.

If driving from major cities:

From Columbus: Take I-71 North to US-62 East (about 2 hours)
From Cleveland: Take I-77 South to US-62 West (about 1.5 hours)
From Pittsburgh: Take I-76 West to I-77 South, then US-62 West (about 2.5 hours)

Navigating the Area

While having a car offers the most flexibility, there are other options:

Guided tours: Many companies offer day trips or multi-day tours of the area.
Bicycle rentals: Some areas have bike rental services for a more immersive experience.
Horse and buggy rides: For short trips, some Amish-owned businesses offer authentic buggy rides.

Respecting Local Traffic

Remember that you’ll be sharing the road with horse-drawn buggies. Follow these tips:

Drive slowly and cautiously, especially on hills and curves.
Pass buggies only when it’s safe, giving them plenty of room.
Be prepared for buggy traffic to increase around sunrise and sunset.

Accessibility

While many unique accommodations strive to be accessible, the nature of some (like treehouses or restored historic buildings) may present challenges for travelers with mobility issues. Always contact the property directly to discuss specific accessibility needs. Some bed and breakfasts and modern hotels in the area offer fully accessible rooms and amenities.

You May Also Like: Best Places To Visit In USA For First Time

Best Times to Visit

Amish Country Ohio is beautiful year-round, but each season offers a unique experience.

Spring (March to May)

Weather: Mild temperatures, occasional rain showers
Pros: Blooming flowers, baby farm animals, less crowded
Cons: Some muddy roads, variable weather
Events: Amish Country Quilt Show (March)

Summer (June to August)

Weather: Warm to hot, occasional thunderstorms
Pros: Perfect for outdoor activities, farmers markets in full swing
Cons: Peak tourist season, higher prices
Events: Holmes County Fair (August)

Fall (September to November)

Weather: Cool and crisp, occasional rain
Pros: Beautiful fall foliage, harvest season
Cons: Can be busy with leaf-peepers
Events: Ohio’s Amish Country Fall Harvest Festival (September)

Winter (December to February)

Weather: Cold with occasional snow
Pros: Cozy atmosphere, holiday decorations, fewer tourists
Cons: Some attractions may have limited hours
Events: Holmes County Christmas Cookie Tour (December)

The best time to visit depends on your preferences. For a balance of good weather and fewer crowds, consider late spring or early fall.

Family-Friendly Accommodations and Activities

Amish Country Ohio offers numerous options for families looking for unique stays and activities.

Family-Friendly Lodgings

The Farm at Walnut Creek: Offers family-sized cabins and hands-on farm experiences.
Amish Country Lodging: Many of their properties feature multiple bedrooms and kid-friendly amenities like game rooms.
The Mohicans Treehouse Resort: Several treehouses can accommodate families and offer an adventurous stay.

Kid-Friendly Activities

The Farm at Walnut Creek: Feed exotic animals and learn about farm life.
Amish & Mennonite Heritage Center: Interactive exhibits about Amish history and culture.
Hershberger’s Farm & Bakery: Petting zoo, buggy rides, and delicious treats.
Yoder’s Amish Home: Tours of an Amish home and schoolhouse.

Safety Considerations

Always supervise children around farm animals.
Be cautious on rural roads, especially with horse-drawn buggies present.
Check age restrictions for unique accommodations like treehouses.
Bring appropriate clothing and footwear for farm visits and outdoor activities.

Eco-Friendly and Sustainable Stays

Sustainability is becoming increasingly important in Amish Country Ohio, with many accommodations embracing eco-friendly practices.

Green Accommodations

The Inn at Honey Run: Features Earth-sheltered rooms and a focus on conservation.
The Wallhouse Hotel: LEED Gold-certified hotel with energy-efficient systems.
Glenmont Yurts: Low-impact structures that blend with the natural environment.

Sustainable Practices

Solar power: Some properties, like certain cabins at Amish Country Lodging, use solar panels.
Local and organic food: Many bed and breakfasts source ingredients from local Amish farms.
Water conservation: Properties like The Barn Inn use low-flow fixtures and rainwater collection.

Supporting Conservation

The Inn at Honey Run maintains a 56-acre nature preserve.
Some farm stays participate in sustainable agriculture practices.
Look for accommodations that support local wildlife conservation efforts.

Capturing your unique stay in Amish Country Ohio can be tricky but rewarding. Here are some tips:

Photogenic Spots

Rolling hills and farmland (especially during sunset)
Covered bridges
Amish buggies on country roads (from a safe distance)
Unique accommodations like treehouses or yurts

Respectful Photography

Never photograph Amish people without their explicit permission.
Focus on landscapes, architecture, and your accommodation instead.
Be mindful of privacy when photographing Amish homes or businesses.

Popular hashtags:

#AmishCountryOhio
#OhioFindItHere
#UniqueStaysOhio

Accounts to follow:

@OhioFindItHere (official Ohio tourism account)
@VisitAmishCountry
Individual accommodation accounts for inspiration and updates

Remember to be present in the moment and not let photo-taking overshadow your experience.

You May Also Like: Travel Backpacks For Women

Local Artisans and Crafts

Amish Country Ohio is renowned for its high-quality, handcrafted goods. Many unique accommodations showcase these items.

Amish-Made Furniture and Decor

The Barn Inn features Amish-made quilts and furniture in guest rooms.
Some cabins at Amish Country Lodging are furnished with locally crafted pieces.

Shopping for Authentic Goods

Walnut Creek Cheese: Large variety of Amish-made foods and crafts.
Lehman’s Hardware: Historic store with non-electric appliances and traditional crafts.
Miller’s Dry Goods: Fabrics, quilts, and handmade items.

Hands-On Experiences

Quilting classes at local shops
Candle-making workshops
Pottery demonstrations at Holmes County Pottery

Consider choosing accommodations that offer or are close to these artisanal experiences for a more immersive stay.

Romantic Getaways

Amish Country Ohio provides a perfect backdrop for couples seeking a romantic escape.

Most Romantic Accommodations

The Inn at Honey Run: Serene setting with private cottages.
Glenmont Yurts: Cozy and unique for stargazing.
The Mohicans Treehouse Resort: Little Owl treehouse designed specifically for couples.

Special Packages

Many B&Bs offer romance packages including amenities like champagne, chocolates, and couples’ massages.
Some properties provide special setups for proposals or anniversaries.

Romantic Activities

Wine tasting at local vineyards
Couples’ cooking classes featuring Amish cuisine
Scenic hot air balloon rides over the countryside
Horse-drawn carriage rides through picturesque towns

Budget-Friendly Options

Experiencing the unique stays of Amish Country Ohio doesn’t have to break the bank.

Affordable Unique Stays

Amish Country Campsites: Offer a budget-friendly way to immerse in nature.
Holmes with a View Cottage: Affordable rates with stunning vistas.
Simple Life Amish Tours: Offers stays with Amish families at reasonable prices.

Money-Saving Tips

Visit during off-peak seasons (late fall to early spring, excluding holidays).
Look for midweek specials at B&Bs and cabins.
Prepare your own meals if staying in accommodations with kitchens.

Free or Low-Cost Activities

Self-guided driving tours of Amish Country
Visiting Amish cheese factories and markets
Hiking in Holmes County State Park
Attending free community events like barn raisings (when available)

Amish Cultural Etiquette

Understanding and respecting Amish culture is crucial for a positive experience in Amish Country Ohio.

Do’s and Don’ts

Do:

Dress modestly (avoid revealing clothing)
Ask permission before taking photos of Amish people or their property
Respect the Sabbath (Sunday) when many businesses will be closed

Don’t:

Stare or point at Amish individuals
Enter private property without permission
Use flash photography around Amish people or horses

Common Misconceptions

Not all Amish groups have the same rules (some may use more modern technology than others)
Amish people don’t pose for photos, but many are friendly and open to respectful interaction
The Amish do pay taxes and vote in some elections

Being a Responsible Visitor

Support Amish-owned businesses
Be open to learning about their way of life
Respect their choice to live differently
Drive carefully on roads shared with buggies

By following these guidelines and choosing unique, respectful accommodations, visitors can have an enriching experience in Amish Country Ohio while supporting local communities and traditions.

Conclusion

Amish Country Ohio offers an array of unique places to stay that cater to every taste and preference. From cozy bed and breakfasts and rustic cabins to treehouses and farm stays, the region’s diverse accommodation options provide visitors with unforgettable experiences that go far beyond a simple place to rest.

These distinctive lodgings not only offer comfort and charm but also serve as gateways to the rich culture, history, and natural beauty of Amish Country Ohio. Whether you’re seeking a romantic getaway, a family adventure, or a solo retreat, the unique stays in this enchanting region promise to create lasting memories and a deeper appreciation for the simple pleasures in life.

As you plan your visit to Amish Country Ohio, consider stepping off the beaten path and choosing one of these extraordinary accommodations. By doing so, you’ll not only ensure a comfortable and enjoyable stay but also gain a more authentic and immersive experience of this captivating destination. The unique places to stay in Amish Country Ohio are more than just lodgings – they’re an integral part of the journey, offering insights, adventures, and connections that will stay with you long after your visit has ended.