Discover the key differences between interest rate swaps and caps, plus a step-by-step guide to converting cap premiums to basis points per year for smarter hedging in 2026’s market.
Table of Contents
Navigating Interest Rates: Swaps vs. Caps in 2025
Choosing the right interest rate hedge can feel overwhelming. Do you lock in a fixed rate with a swap? Or buy protection with a cap? The answer depends on your risk tolerance and market view.
This guide breaks it down. We will compare swaps and caps. We will also show you a key trick: converting a cap’s upfront cost into an annual rate. This makes comparing your options simple.
Quick Tip: For a fast way to see the cost of a cap, use the Chatham Rate Cap Calculator. It does the math for you.
Let’s dive in.
Understanding Interest Rate Swaps
Think of a swap as a fixed-rate shield. You agree to trade your floating rate payments for a fixed one. This gives you cost certainty.
How Swaps Work
You and another party exchange cash flows. You pay a fixed rate. You receive a floating rate (like SOFR). The payments are netted out. If SOFR rises above your fixed rate, you get paid the difference. This offsets your higher borrowing costs.
The Good and The Bad
- Pros:
- Predictable payments. Great for budgeting.
- Usually no upfront cost.
- Highly customizable terms.
- Cons:
- Ending the swap early can mean big fees.
- You lose out if market rates fall.
- There is some credit risk involved.
Demystifying Interest Rate Caps
A cap is like an insurance policy against rising rates. You pay a one-time premium. In return, your rate will never go above a set level (the “strike”).
How Caps Work
You buy a cap with a specific strike rate. If the floating rate (like SOFR) jumps above that strike, you receive a payout. This covers the extra interest cost. Your rate is effectively “capped.”
The Good and The Bad
- Pros:
- You still benefit if rates fall.
- No ongoing payments beyond the premium.
- Flexible strike levels to match your budget and needs.
- Cons:
- The upfront premium can be costly.
- It offers no help if rates drop.
- The protection expires, so you may need to buy a new one.
Swap vs. Cap: Key Differences
How do you choose? It comes down to your goal.
- Swaps are for certainty. You want to lock in a rate and sleep well at night.
- Caps are for flexibility. You want protection from high rates but hope to benefit from lower ones.
Think about cost, too. Swaps have no upfront fee but lock you in. Caps have an upfront cost but let you walk away later without penalty.
Why Convert a Cap Premium to Basis Points/Year?
This is the secret to a fair fight. A swap’s cost is an annual rate. A cap’s cost is a one-time fee. How can you compare them?
You spread the cap’s cost over its life. This gives you an “effective annual cost” in basis points (bps/yr). Now you can compare it directly to a swap’s fixed rate.
This makes your decision much clearer.
How to Convert a Cap Premium to BPS/YR
It’s easier than you think. Just follow these steps.
Step 1: Gather Your Numbers
You need three things:
- The premium amount (e.g., $1.5 million on a $100 million loan).
- The loan’s term in years (e.g., 3 years).
- The total loan amount (the “notional”).
Step 2: Do the Math
Use this simple formula:
Annualized Cost (bps/yr) = (Premium / Notional) / Term x 10,000
Let’s break it down with an example.
A Real-World Example
Imagine a $100 million loan for 3 years. You buy a cap for a $1 million premium (1% of the loan).
- Premium / Notional = 1,000,000 / 100,000,000 = 0.01
- Divide by the Term: 0.01 / 3 = 0.00333
- Multiply by 10,000: 0.00333 x 10,000 = 33.33 bps/yr
So, the annual cost of your cap protection is about 33 basis points per year. Add this to your loan’s spread to find your all-in protected rate.
Want to skip the math? Use the Chatham Rate Cap Calculator to get your number instantly.
Looking Ahead to 2026
Market forecasts suggest rates may stabilize or even fall. This makes caps an attractive option. Their upfront cost has dropped, making the annualized bps/yr cost more appealing.
A good strategy is to focus on caps with strikes that balance cost and coverage. Many are now extending existing caps to lock in these lower prices.
The Bottom Line: Which One Is for You?
Your choice is personal. It depends on your market view and needs.
- Choose a Swap if: You need long-term certainty. You are worried rates will rise and want to lock in a cost today.
- Choose a Cap if: You want flexibility. You think rates might fall and don’t want to be locked into a high fixed rate. You might pay off the loan early.
Pro Tip: Always convert the cap premium to bps/yr. Then, compare that number to the swap’s fixed rate. This simple step will reveal the smarter financial choice for you.
Don’t leave your financial future to chance. Understand your options, run the numbers, and build a hedging strategy that protects your profits. Start by calculating your costs today.
